Skip to main content

Robinhood vs. Fidelity: A Deep Dive into Options Trading Features for Day Traders


Introduction

Choosing the right broker for options trading, especially for day trading, can significantly impact your trading experience and success. Here, I compare Robinhood and Fidelity, two prominent players in the brokerage world, focusing on their options trading capabilities, user experience, and which might best serve day traders. I have used both and am currently utilizing Robinhood's new day trading platform.

Robinhood vs. Fidelity: A Deep Dive into Options Trading Features for Day Traders

Trading Platforms

ROBINHOOD:

Platform: Robinhood offers a streamlined, user-friendly mobile app with a straightforward interface designed for simplicity. The desktop (website) version is less comprehensive but still functional. However, Robinhood's newly released online trading platform (October 2024), Robinhood Legend, targets active traders with advanced charting tools, real-time data, and customizable layouts.

Options Trading Features:
  • Commission-Free Trading: Robinhood made headlines with its commission-free trades, which include options.
  • Options Chains: Users can view basic options chains but do not have access to market depth or sophisticated analysis tools.
  • Strategy Builder: Allows for multi-leg options strategies, but it's less robust than some competitors.
  • No Per-Contract Fee: Only a flat fee for options trading, which is beneficial for active traders. (only $0.03 per contract Exchange & Regulatory Fees)
Pros:
  • Easy to use, especially for beginners.
  • Commission-free trading can be very cost-effective for high-volume traders.
  • Access to cryptocurrencies, which aren't available for options trading at Fidelity.
Cons:
  • Limited advanced features for options trading.
  • Basic research tools.
  • Lack of comprehensive analytics.
  • Previous issues with trade execution speed during high volatility periods.

FIDELITY:

Platform: Fidelity's trading platforms include Active Trader Pro, a comprehensive desktop application for advanced traders, a web platform with diverse option analytics, and a mobile app that, although less intuitive than Robinhood's, provides more in-depth analytical tools.

Options Trading Features:
  • Commission: $0.65 per contract, which might add up for frequent traders.
  • Options Strategies: Supports complex options strategies with tools for analysis.
  • Research and Tools: Extensive research tools, options screeners, and analytical charts.
Pros:
  • Rich set of tools for in-depth analysis and strategy planning.
  • Better options for those looking to trade a variety of asset classes beyond stocks and ETFs.
  • Multiple trading platforms tailored for different trader experiences.
Cons:
  • The cost per options contract can be a deterrent for high-volume options traders.
  • The learning curve for Active Trader Pro might be steep for beginners.
  • The mobile platform is not intuitive or streamlined for day trading options.

For New Traders

Robinhood might be more appealing due to:
  • Its user-friendly interface which simplifies the trading process.
  • No commission fees on options, making it easier to start trading without immediate financial pressure.
  • The educational content available through Robinhood Learn, although limited compared to Fidelity.

For Seasoned Day Traders

Fidelity stands out for:
  • Its Active Trader Pro platform offers advanced charting, real-time Level II quotes (market depth), and direct market access.
  • Superior options analytics and strategy tools can help make informed decisions.
  • Fidelity's breadth of investment products is unmatched if you're looking at trading beyond options.

General Recommendation

Robinhood vs. Fidelity: A Deep Dive into Options Trading Features for Day Traders
  • For New Traders: Start with Robinhood if you want simplicity and cost-effectiveness. Its gamification aspects might not be ideal for long-term investment strategy, but it's a good entry point for learning the basics of options trading.
  • For Seasoned Traders: Fidelity provides the tools, research, and order types necessary for sophisticated trading strategies. Its platforms cater to traders who need depth in their trading toolkit.

Conclusion

Both Robinhood and Fidelity have carved out niches in the brokerage industry. 

Robinhood's no-fee structure makes entry into the markets easy, which is excellent for beginners or anyone looking to keep costs down. 

However, for those who delve deeper into options trading, the need for advanced tools, custom order types, and in-depth research might make Fidelity the preferable choice.

Ultimately, your choice between Robinhood and Fidelity for options day trading should align with your trading experience, investment goals, and how much you value platform features versus cost. 

Fidelity might be the best option if you're building a more complex trading strategy or require extensive research capabilities. 

If you're new to trading or prefer a minimalist approach, Robinhood could serve you well, considering its limitations in advanced options trading tools.

Remember, while cost is a significant factor, the quality of the trading platform and tools can significantly influence your trading outcomes, especially in the fast-paced world of options trading.

Ultimately, choose the platform that is compatible with your trading style and system.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Day Trader Behavior Cycles: The Foundations of Change

As I stepped into the realm of trading full-time, I quickly realized how psychology and specific behaviors can positively or negatively affect trader performance. Beginning trading full-time in one of the most hyper-inflated markets and one of the best bull markets in history, I witnessed very volatile and drastic moves.  Having been learning about the market on and off for a couple of years before full-time immersion, I approached it cautiously. However, due to the current market's highly bullish nature, my cautious approach continued to hinder me. As I started participating in the market, I slowly fell into a false sense of security. I knew this wouldn't last forever, but the opportunity was too great to not push and be a part of the crowd. People made lots of money regardless of what or when they bought. Those who held and hoped were rewarded handsomely. As the days, weeks, and months went on, I slowly started to let go of my cautious approach and was making more money and c...
Post a Comment
Read more

Options Trading SPY [-19% +2% +33%] 11/15/24

SPY 1-minute chart 11/15/24. Day Metrics { 2 } Wins { 1 } Loss Day Rating:  EFFECTIVE Overview At 8:30 AM ET, the U.S. Retail Sales for October were released. They showed a modest increase of 0.4% from the previous month, aligning with market expectations. However, core retail sales, which exclude autos, were up by only 0.1% against an expected 0.3%. SPY's price did not move in reaction to the news. However, we gapped down from the previous day and are in a downtrend. Trades [1]   RZ Bounce Entry:  Since we already had a significant gap down and started to push up from a pre-market low, I wanted to re-test the reaction zone and enter calls for a bounce. Exit:  I anticipated too early and gave it too much time before cutting losses. The bounce area was lower than I was willing to hold. [2]   (-) TL Reject Entry:   SPY's price bounced decently, so   I waited for the test of the (-) TL. Exit:  I was rewarded with a firm rejection in my favor. I locke...
Post a Comment
Read more

Options Trading SPY [+6%] 11/18/24

  SPY 1-minute chart 11/18/24. Day Metrics { 1 } Win { 0 } Losses Day Rating: INEFFECTIVE Overview There was no significant economic news released today that could have the potential to move the market. Following yesterday's sell-off, SPY's price is bouncing off the lows. We formed some intra-day reaction zones, but the price action is a slow grind upwards. Trades [1]   RZ Reject Entry:  I missed the opportunity to get in on the grind upwards, so I remained highly patient for either a pullback or a reject entry. I waited and was able to get into an entry at the upper reaction zone. Exit: Price continued to want to grind up, so I managed to lock in some gains before the price continued upwards. 🎥 Trading Session Recording 🎥 on  𝕏 -or- Review/Next Steps I completely missed the entry for a RZ bounce or the (-) TL Breakout Bounce. I was too slow to adapt my thinking. I waited patiently for the lower (-) TL Breakout Bounce/ VWAP Re-test, but that never came, so I ...
Post a Comment
Read more